A wide landscape shot of a hillside in Bransdale under a cloudy, overcast sky. In the foreground, dozens of young saplings are protected by tall, pale pink plastic tree guards, protruding from a rugged ground covered in dry brush and fallen branches. In the background, a steep green hill is divided by traditional dry stone walls, with patches of melting snow visible on the grass. A dense line of evergreen trees sits on the left ridge, while the rest of the slope shows signs of recent clearing and reforestation.

Among the Tree Guards of Bransdale

In Bransdale today, work continued among the ranks of tree guards set out over recent winters. The task was to fell the self-seeded conifer saplings that have spread so thickly through this corner of Bloworth Wood. New woodland does not simply grow and look after itself; it demands steady, patient management. From the valley floor, the guards climb in a long creep up the steep far side, marking the slow advance of the young wood.

Tree guards are meant to give saplings a fair start, shielding them from browsing deer and hungry rabbits. Yet they carry an environmental cost that is easy to overlook. Many plastic tubes are never recovered. They split, scatter across the landscape, or become trapped within the very trees they were meant to protect. Because they are not biodegradable, they must be collected by hand, a task too often left undone1‘Plastics and Tree Guards’. 2023. Woodlands.co.uk <https://www.woodlands.co.uk/blog/practical-guides/plastics-and-tree-guards/> [accessed 19 February 2026].

The guards used here by the National Trust are however designed to biodegrade and return to the soil as compost. Some are already beginning to break down, even while the young trees inside have yet to outgrow their protective shells.


Posted

in

,

by

Comments

5 responses to “Among the Tree Guards of Bransdale”

  1. Reece avatar
    Reece

    I’ve seen plastic tree guard litter all over the place, there really needs to be an effort to trace all past woodland schemes and make sure the plastic is removed. A few years ago I also saw some in Little Kildale Wood at the far eastern end near the Leven, and the trees looked like mature trees, so this litter remains for decades. Those trees must have been planted in the 80s, early 90s at the latest.

    Plastic spirals in hedges are even worse, those break down into fragments even easier than the tube tree guards do.

  2. Peter Astle avatar
    Peter Astle

    From the RFS website:
    “Although there is currently no public access through Bloworth Wood, plans are in process to develop permissive paths to connect the woodland to the wider valley network of cycle and walking routes both in Bransdale and in the neighbouring Farndale Valley.”
    Wondered if you know whether the situation remains unchanged today i.e. is there still no public access? A nice little circuit upto the Badger Stone could be made via the wood.

    1. Fhithich avatar
      Fhithich

      I haven’t heard anything but I’ll ask around. Unfortunately the ranger who wrote that article has now retired.

      1. Fhithich avatar
        Fhithich

        As a follow-up, the lead ranger has not heard of any such plans.

        1. Peter Astle avatar
          Peter Astle

          Interesting!
          The paragraph I quoted still appears on the RFS website along with the retired ranger’s email address:
          https://rfs.org.uk/conversion-of-mature-conifer-plantation-to-mixed-broadleaves/

Leave a Reply to Peter Astle Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *