A day of mixed feelings. The Mammal Society ran a harvest mouse survey workshop, and Flamingo Land, in the south-east of North Yorkshire, played host. I must admit I went with misgivings.
British law requires licensed zoos to meet minimum standards that include animal welfare. In 2024 the Kent-based Aspinall Foundation published research alleging more than 3,000 breaches of standards at 29 accredited zoos across Europe, British ones among them1The Canary. “UK zoos breaching basic animal welfare standards as investigation shows standards not fit for purpose.” 18 May 2024. https://www.thecanary.co/global/world-analysis/2024/05/18/uk-zoos-animal-welfare/. It’s only right to say, Flamingo Land was not among the zoos named. But theme parks are not my cup of tea in any case.
The staff were welcoming and proud of the park’s conservation work, and the pride looked genuine.
Zoos have a past that sits badly with their present. They began as menageries of the exotic, a by-product of empire, built on control and run for profit. Nobody pretended otherwise. Conservation arrived later and now runs through the publicity like lettering through a stick of rock. The profit remains. Zoos say captivity serves conservation and education, and the Aspinall report suggests that some pay for the claim with their animals’ welfare, keeping them at needless risk in unsuitable conditions.
Captivity brings its own troubles. Few animals are suited to a sedentary life, and confinement can expose them to infections they would otherwise avoid.
After looking along the banks of Costa Beck for delicate harvest mice nests, we were taken inside the black rhino enclosure. A huge shed with concrete and steel fittings, a flickering artificial light and no company. The two males were kept well apart. We were told black rhinos are somewhat solitary in the wild, which did not make the place feel less sad.
Keeping species in zoos is a distraction. It soothes visitors into believing the animals are safe because they are behind bars. A zoo is fundamentally a place of entertainment. Conservation should truly mean tackling whatever threatens these animals in the wild.
- 1The Canary. “UK zoos breaching basic animal welfare standards as investigation shows standards not fit for purpose.” 18 May 2024. https://www.thecanary.co/global/world-analysis/2024/05/18/uk-zoos-animal-welfare/ ↩︎

Leave a Reply